Moving over to Noe Valley, we find eco+historical project #3…1436 Sanchez St.

Set in a row of nicely-restored homes out in what us hilltop folk call “Noe Flats”, 1436 Sanchez is a 1903 home that had been in a single family for at least 90 years and vacant for the last 4 or 5.
On the bright side:
- The location is great
- The neighboring houses are all restored
- There’s a single fireplace
- There’s an existing, albeit scary, garage
- There are 3 living levels (but the lowest level, above the garage, is mostly basement)
On the not-so-bright side:
- Like most homes of its era, it’s uninsulated
- The wiring is old (it still has gas/electric fixtures)
- The plumbing is old
- The kitchen has nothing worth saving
- Although apparently huge, there are just 1200 sqft. w/2BR and 1BA
So what are we going to do?
We’re eco+historical! That means we’re going to make this a great family house…and along the way, we plan to get ourselves a LEED Platinum rating for it. Will we get there? We’ll see. But we’ll definitely make this old, drafty, lead paint-filled home a healthy, attractive, family-centered bastion of efficiency and sustainability.
We’ll be blogging the entire process from concept to completion, so stay tuned.
As-Builts
There’s a detailed post on the main eco+historical site on the as-built drawings, but we’ll include a summary here so it’s all in one place. We worked with Fog City As-builts to capture the dimensions of the existing home and site and get them into CAD so that we could start on the design of the remodeled home. In just a couple of days they were able to give us the floor plans…
…and some 3D cutaways showing each floor
…and a full rendering of the front of the house that almost exactly matches a recent photo!


Design Concepts
With the as-built plans in hand, our architects, Feldman Architecture, set off to create a new design for the house that would make better use of the space that the home has. Although the house appears huge, due to the 3 apparent living levels over the garage, the lowest level was unfinished and only had a 6′ head height since the garage went straight in under the house and restricted the available space. We suggested to Feldman that we could change the garage from going in under the house, level with the sidewalk, to sloping down starting at the garage door so that by the time the garage passes under the house, it’s low enough down that the area that’s currently basement could be made into a full living level with 8′ ceilings.
Combining that with some good use of wall dormers (see our post on adding floor space in the same footprint) in the back of the top story will greatly enlarge the floor space we can use in the existing house and a small addition in the back, to match the neighbors, will make the two lowest levels great family living spaces.
Check out the concept drawings. In my humble opinion, Feldman, and our project architect, Bridgett Shank, did a simply fabulous job.



Note some of the great things that they accomplished with this design:
- Family-friendly 3 Bedrooms and 2 Baths on the top story
- Master bed has views to downtown San Francisco
- Kids bedrooms get a great shared deck in the rear
- Main level takes existing LR/DR/Kitchen, grows the kitchen and adds a Family Room, Powder Room and Coat Closet
- New ground level has a suite-like 2 BRs, 1 Bath, and a huge Rec Room that looks out onto the garage’s Green Roof
- New garage level has room for 2 tandem cars plus a huge amount of storage
Next step…get this into 3D CAD like the as-builts!
Final Plans
Oct 15, 2010…the plans are done!
It took us some time, but I think we’ve really come up with a great plan for the remodel. We’ve scaled back a bit to manage costs, but we still have both a Family Room off the kitchen and an amazing Rec Room/Man Cave down on the bottom level – with its own kitchenette, no less. The Master Bedroom is much improved in both size and layout, giving it room for not only the bed and nightstands, but a couple of chairs, a view of downtown SF, and some built-in bookshelves and dresser drawers. Check it out and let us know what you think!
Garage Level
Keeping the size of the garage more or less the same as it currently is, we’ll replace the circa-1924 concrete with rusted-out rebar, add proper drainage, and connect it to the house for the first time via an interior stair.

Ground Level / Basement
This level does currently exist as an unfinished basement, but with barely a 6′ head height. We’ll excavate to get an 8′ head height and extend it in the rear of the home, giving this floor two good-sized bedrooms, a full bath, a huge Rec Room/Home Theatre, a laundry, and a kitchenette to keep the wine, beer, Perrier and microwave popcorn at hand…
First Floor
This is the original social level of the home. Unfortunately, the original version had no bathroom, no strong connection to the back yard, and an awkward kitchen. By making our small rear addition and opening up the floor plan in a more contemporary way, we get a great Entry and Living Room with the original fireplace, a new Powder Room and coat closet plus a huge Kitchen connected to new Dining and Family Rooms – with a wall of windows and French doors opening to the newly-elevated rear yard.

Top Floor
The original top floor sported just two bedrooms and one bath…and lots of pink carpet. Um…yeah.
In our re-envisioned top floor, we added dormers in the back to take advantage of the full width of the home and enabling us to split the rear bedroom into two bedrooms and a bath. The rear addition below for the new Family Room serves as the foundation for a huge rear deck for these two bedrooms and, with plantings on the deck and in the rear yard, give them a lovely green-space view. The front bedroom always had a view of downtown San Francisco, but enlarging the front windows (and upgrading them from the lovely aluminum sliders there now) only serves to improve that view. By dropping the ceiling height of the Living Room below, we gain extra square footage in the new MBR plus we squeeze out a Master Closet and Master Bath with double sinks and a huge walk-in shower.

Front and Rear Views
The front view shows just how little the house actually appears to change from the original (which I’ve included from MapJack for reference), preserving the historic identity and details of the home. The dimensions of more or less everything remain the same and there will be no above-ground vertical additions to the home. Only the new dormers really give away that there are significant changes upstairs, and they are set back pretty far from the front.


While seeing the new rear view has much more substantive changes, raising grade to enable the new Family Room to walk straight out to the yard and showing the new rear upper deck shared by the two rear upper bedrooms. At the roof, a small peak illustrates the original sharply-peaked roofline, transitioning to the new, more shallow roof that extends to the outer walls, enabling us to double the available width of living space in the rear top story, capturing space that was previously lost to the sharp roofline.



11 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 17, 2010 at 3:52 am
noearch
Looks like a very interesting project. We are just finishing up a similar renovation to our 1904 Victorian in Noe Valley not far from your project. We did almost everything: Complete new foundations and seismic upgrade, all new plumbing, new electrical, 3 new baths, removed an old out of character rear sun porch, added a new 3 story rear addition that is compatible with the existing steep roofs, new windows, insulation, rear deck. We are now restoring original softwood floors, interior trim, etc.
Our permit process was fairly complex; took about 9 months, had to CEQA forms and revise some drawings and meet with the preservation specialists.
My partner and I are both architects as well. If interested at some point, I can give you a tour and talk about our experience. Good luck with your project.
Doug
May 17, 2010 at 4:56 pm
mrfrancophile
CEQA! Wow…that’s hardcore. Sounds like what you’re doing is very very similar to the house we just sold at 173 Downey – removed an quick-and-dirty sunporch addition from the 50′s or 60′s and replaced it w/a 3-story addition as well. I’d love to see what you’ve done with your Victorian…if there’s anything I’ve learned from architecture and construction is that every project is a learning process and you can learn a lot from other folks’ projects too.
May 18, 2010 at 1:36 am
noearch
Yea, it was a pretty substantial project, and very pleased with the results. The foundation work and seismic upgrade was extensive, and expensive, but well worth it.
Once we removed the old rear 3 story porch and replaced it with a much more sensitive addition, the entire rear elevation changed, for the better, and added a lot more usable square footage.
Let me know by email, and we can perhaps meet here for a tour. Thanks much.
doug s.
October 16, 2010 at 1:15 pm
1436 Sanchez Plans are D.O.N.E. « eco+historical
[...] out all of the new final plans on the project page here. eco+historical founder, Josh Mogal We created eco+historical homes to remake historic houses [...]
December 17, 2011 at 6:10 am
SF has best Green Building Policy says WorldGBC « eco+historical
[...] new Green Team in the San Francisco Planning and Building process did approve our 1436 Sanchez project for expedited processing since we were targeting LEED Platinum, saving us perhaps 3-4 months in the [...]
August 26, 2012 at 11:40 pm
1566 Sells in a Flash « eco+historical
[...] our focus is shifting to 1436 Sanchez, just up the [...]
January 28, 2013 at 3:46 am
Kay
Thank you so much for posting the updates being made to this house. It will be a lovely home when it is completed. My husband’s family owned the home since 1920, when his grandmother, Arria Glenn Voss Jones purchased the house. It was Arria’s daughter Louise Jones who was gifted the home prior to her mother’s death. Arria’s last child of six and Bill’s father, Victor Jones was born in this home and the family had many family gatherings around the kitchen table. We would love to see the house when it is complete and hope you will let us know when the home goes on the market. Thank you for caring for this family home. Kay Jones
January 28, 2013 at 4:21 am
mrfrancophile
Kay, Thank you for your kind words and an even greater thanks for the additional information about the history of the house and of the people who called it home. We’re in the final stages of our project and the house should be complete by late February. I will surely let you know when we’re planning to have our first private open house party and hope that you and any other family members that are interested will feel free to come. I will certainly be there and would be delighted to meet you. Sadly, we did have to remove the large tree behind the home since it was beset by parasites and could not be saved, but where one tree once lived, we will soon have four. Hopefully I’ll get my act together to do some more posts soon since I’ve done little to document the project since we started last February. If you remember the original home, I think you’ll find the updated version just a little…er…different. Hopefully in a good way!
January 29, 2013 at 6:36 pm
Kay
Thank you so much for the quick reply. There are a few of us who would love to see what you’ve done and are looking forward to visiting when the house is complete. Some of us have even been keeping an eye on the progress, stopping by once in a while. The tree will not be missed – not to worry. The openness of the main floor, the back addition and the changes to the lower level are just what the house needed. Can you believe that a family of eight lived there for many years – minus the pink carpet – Louise had that done much later. Thanks again for the invitation, we look forward to meeting you. Kay Jones
March 13, 2013 at 6:39 am
Pattabi Seshadri
Hi Josh
My wife and I visited 1436 Sanchez during your open house and were blown away by the attention to detail. We got a lot of inspiration for our Noe Valley home which is under renovation right now. One thing that left an impression on us was the structured wiring. Do you mind sharing how you did it, how many cables of which type you ran to each room, etc.?
March 13, 2013 at 2:24 pm
mrfrancophile
It’s always nice to hear when someone appreciates your efforts…thanks for the comments! When the walls are all open during a gut rehab, adding wire is pretty easy. Rule of thumb is just that you run CAT-5 or CAT-6 to each bedroom/office space and the kitchen plus to any place you think you might have AV equipment or your cable modem or the like. Since I also like to add multiple Sonos wireless audio zones, I put speakers in the ceilings of the social spaces and in the garden and home run all of those wires to a single location – usually my mechanical/utility room – where I set up all of my AV equipment. Although the Sonos equipment can be placed anywhere since it’s all synched wirelessly, it’s easier to co-locate the units and run all of the wire to one place.
My sole exception is the Master Bedroom where we put the Sonos unit in the closet and wire the speakers to that. The reason for this is that I also wire the MBR for HDMI from the wall across from the bed to the closet, so all of the MBR AV is in the closet. While you may want to control the MBR zone audio from your smart phone, you’re unlikely to want to watch a movie with a disc you insert in the BluRay player in the AV Room downstairs, then run up to your room to watch it. Better to have a player in the closet if you want to watch movies. If you really love TV in the bedroom (which I don’t like to have), you can put an AV receiver in the closet with the BluRay player and a second cable box or the like and go to town. I’m not a huge fan of shipping the video all over the home from a central location…I just don’t think there’s that much demand for it.
Hope that answers your question. I also do some consulting on the side for people doing their own rehabs, so if you need a little assistance with your own project, feel free to drop me a line. Good luck!